PROJECT BASE LEARNING
PBL
https://sites.google.com/a/harmonytx.org/pbl/hs-students/hs-level-3-tasks
Project Base Learning
The Project Based Learning initiative, launched during the 2013-2014 school year, addresses
the increased need for students to acquire critical-thinking, problem-solving, collaboration and communication skills, otherwise know as 21st century skills. Through Project Based Learning (PBL), students are exposed to deep learning experiences that are inquiry based, student-centered, and integrated to the curriculum. The Harmony approach is to maintain the focus on standards-based and student-centered teaching while enriching and extending the learning of students through PBL work. The goal is to promote not only collaborative skills and student ownership of learning but also to promote student success in state and national standards. |
Engineering projects over the years
SODA Machine
Seniors 2017-18
Build a soda machine |
House chore
students have a PBL project "house chore" where they design a solution to a house chore.
|
Robotics arm
students design and build a robotics arm to be able to help community with proshetics
|
Solar Rollers
solar rollers RC car, students use solar cells and a kit of materials to build a RC solar car and compete against other schools
|
Aquaponics
students build an aquaponics project where plants feed fish and fish feed plants .
|
House puppy
students from engineering design and build a house for puppies that allows the dog to be kept warm thanks to sustainable energy "solar cell panels"
|
Desk Cleaner with arduino
|
DRONE x
Harmony Engineering seniors build a drone from scratch, they design build test rebuild and finally have a working prototype
|
Autonomous Lawnmower
student design, test and build an autonomous lawn-mower with the use of Arduino micro-controllers.
|
other helpful ideas for projects
Make a brand new computer out of old components
SAMPLES for PBLs
https://sites.google.com/view/stem-sos-gears-pulley-drives/pbl-project?authuser=3
https://sites.google.com/view/stemsosmech-system-pltw-po/home
https://sites.google.com/view/stemsosmech-system-pltw-po/home
More info ...
The Project Based Learning initiative, launched during the 2013-2014 school year, addresses
the increased need for students to acquire critical-thinking, problem-solving, collaboration
and communication skills, otherwise know as 21st century skills. Through Project Based
Learning (PBL), students are exposed to deep learning experiences that are inquiry based,
student-centered, and integrated to the curriculum. The Harmony approach is to maintain
the focus on standards-based and student-centered teaching while enriching and extending
the learning of students through PBL work. The goal is to promote not only collaborative skills
and student ownership of learning but also to promote student success in state and national
standards.
What is Project-Based Learning?
Project Based Learning is an instructional approach that emphasizes critical-thinking,
collaboration and personalized learning. In project-based learning, student groups engage in
meaningful inquiry that is of personal interest to them. These projects are based on problems
which are real-life oriented, curriculum-based, and often interdisciplinary. Learners decide
how to approach a problem and what activities or processes they will perform. They collect
information from a variety of sources, analyze, synthesize and derive understanding from it.
The real-world focus of PBL activities is central to the process because it motivates students
and adds value to their work. Their learning is connected to something real and involves life
skills such as collaboration and reflection. Technology enables students and teachers in
various phases of the PBL process. At the end of the PBL, students demonstrate their newly
acquired knowledge and are evaluated by how much they have learned and how well they
communicate it. Students also conduct self-evaluation to assess their own growth and
learning. Throughout this process, the teacher's role is to guide and advise students, rather
than to direct and manage student work.
What are the components of Project-Based Learning?
According to the Buck Institute for Education there are eight essential components of
meaningful PBL experiences. These essentials are summarized below.
1. Significant content: The project focuses on important knowledge and concepts derived
from the standards and targets essential understanding in the course. Students should find
the content to be significant in terms of their own lives and interests. A well designed PBL is
an effective vehicle for understanding content more deeply than by traditional methods such
as lectures and textbooks.
2. A Need to Know: Teachers powerfully activate students’ need to know content by
launching a project with an “entry event” that engages student interest and initiates
questioning. The entry event can be anything that sparks student inquiry such as a video, a
discussion, a guest speaker, a field trip, a laboratory experience, etc. In contrast,
announcing a project with a packet of papers will likely not create excitement and an
atmosphere of active learning. Simply telling students that they should learn something
because they will need it later does not motivate them. With a compelling student project,
the reason for learning relevant material becomes personal and purposeful to the student.
3. A Driving Question: After the discussion and brainstorming, students create a Driving
Question to focus their efforts. A good Driving Question captures the heart of the project in
clear, compelling language. The Question should be provocative, open-ended, complex, and
linked to the core of what we want students to learn. It could be abstract, concrete, or
focused on solving a problem. The Driving Question allows students to understand why they
are undertaking a project as well as the sequence of activities that ensues from their
personal challenge.
4. Student Choice and Voice: Students’ interest is captured by a challenging question that
is selected and crafted by the students. This provides the student Choice to the project.
The requirements of the projects such as project report, digital and oral presentations, visual
demonstrations etc. provide Student Voice to the project. The Student Choice and Voice
makes the project meaningful to the students. The more Voice and Choice for the student,
the greater the ownership of the learning will be. However, projects should be designed with
the extent of student choice that best fits each student. On the limited-choice end of the
scale, learners can select what topic to study or choose how to design, create, and present
products. As a middle ground, teachers might provide a limited menu of options to prevent
students from becoming overwhelmed by choices. On the “the more the better” end of the
scale, students can decide what product they will create, what resources they will use, how
they will structure their time or even their topic and Driving Question.
5. 21st Century Skills: Collaboration is central to the PBL learning experience. A project
should give students opportunities to build valuable 21st century skills such as collaboration,
communication, critical thinking, and the use of technology, which will serve them well in the
workplace and in life. Once students have decided on the Driving Question, they form teams
of three or four and begin planning how they would work together. Each team regularly
pauses to review their progress. Teachers can help grow these collaboration skills by using
team building techniques and time/task organizers. Teachers in a Project Based Learning
environment also assess these skills and provide frequent opportunities for students to
assess themselves.
6. Inquiry and Innovation: Brainstorming sessions as a class helps students generate new
ideas and questions. Student team discussion allows opportunities to fine-tune their own
Driving Questions and to discuss resources and procedures. Students find project work to be
more meaningful if they conduct real inquiry that begins with their own questions, leads to a
search for resources and the discovery of answers, and which ultimately leads to generating
new questions, testing ideas, and drawing their own conclusions. With real inquiry comes
innovation – a new answer to a Driving Question, a new product, a new solution to a
problem. Students are not expected to simply reproduce provided information in a pretty
format. The teacher’s task is to create the context for real inquiry in the classroom and to
guide students through the process.
7. Feedback and Revision: As students develop their ideas and products, student teams
use rubrics and exemplars to review and critique one another’s work. The teacher checks
research notes, reviews rough drafts and plans, and meets with teams to monitor their
progress. The mentoring process of monitoring and feedback is formalized and structured so
all student teams have guidance from their teacher throughout the duration of the project.
Students learn through this mentoring that first attempts do not always result in high quality
and that revisions are a frequent feature of real-world work. In addition to providing direct
feedback, a teacher coaches students in using rubrics or other sets of criteria to critique one
another’s work. Teachers can arrange for experts or adult mentors to provide feedback,
which is especially meaningful to students because of the source.
8. Publicly Presented Product: Student teams present their findings, conclusions, and
solutions to audiences such as peers, parents, representatives of community, business,
government organizations and professionals from various industries. Students answer
questions and reflect on how they completed the project, next steps they might take, and
what they gained in terms of knowledge and skills and pride. When they present their work to
a real audience, they connect to real life through their PBL projects. These projects become
authentic when the process replicates real-life tasks and students are no longer observers
but participants in real life experiences.
What is Standards-Focused PBL?
There is no one accepted definition of PBL. However, BIE defines standards-focused PBL as
a systematic teaching method that engages students in learning knowledge and skills
through an extended inquiry process structured around complex, authentic questions
and carefully designed products and tasks. This definition encompasses a spectrum
ranging from brief projects of one to two weeks based on a single subject in one classroom
to year long, interdisciplinary projects that involve community participation and adults
outside the school.
More important than the definition itself are the attributes of effective projects. You will find
that the BIE planning model is based on a number of criteria that distinguish carefully planned
projects from other extended activities in the classroom.
Outstanding projects...
● Recognize students’ inherent drive to learn, their capability to do important work, and
their need to be taken seriously by putting them at the center of the learning
process.
● Engage students in the central concepts and principles of a discipline. The project
work is central rather than peripheral to the curriculum.
● Highlight provocative issues or questions that lead students to in-depth exploration of
authentic and important topics.
● Require the use of essential tools and skills, including technology, for learning,
self-management, and project management.
● Specify products that solve problems, explain dilemmas, or present information
generated through investigation, research, or reasoning.
● Include multiple products that permit frequent feedback and consistent opportunities
for student to learn from experience.
● Use performance-based assessments that communicate high expectations, present
rigorous challenges, and require a range of skills and knowledge.
● Encourage collaboration in some form, either through small groups, student-led
presentation, or whole-class evaluations of project results.
The BIE model for PBL also addresses a singular need in the field of PBL: to create
standards-focused projects that fit well with the era of accountability and performance.
Often projects have been used as fun or change-of-pace events completed after students
have been pushed through homework assignments, lectures, and tests.
In standards-based PBL, students are pulled through the curriculum by a Driving
Question or authentic problem that creates a need to know the material. The Driving
Question is tied to content standards in the curriculum, and assessment is explicitly designed
to evaluate the students’ knowledge of the content.
Similarly, Project Based Learning is sometimes equated with inquiry-based or experiential
learning. Though PBL shares some overlapping characteristics with these two terms,
standards-focused PBL is designed to acknowledge the importance of standards and
evaluation of student learning. In an era of accountability, with testing and performance
uppermost in the minds of parents and educators, it is imperative that all instructional
methods incorporate high standards, rigorous challenges, and valid assessment methods.
References
Solomon, G. (2003). Project-Based Learning: a Primer. Retrieved from
http://www.techlearning.com/db_area/archives/TL/2003/01/project.php
Grant, M. (2002). Getting a grip on Project-Based Learning: Theory, Cases and
Recommendations. Retrieved from http://www.ncsu.edu/meridian/win2002/514
Larmer, J., Mergendoller, J. (2010). 8 Essentials for Project-Based Learning. Retrieved from
http://www.bie.org/tools/freebies/Project Based Learning for the 21st Century
Markham, Thom, John Larmer, and Jason Louis. Ravitz. Project Based Learning Handbook: A
Guide to Standards-focused Project Based Learning for Middle and High School Teachers.
Novato, CA: Buck Institute for Education, 2003. Print.
How does Project Based Learning look like at Harmony Schools?
Harmony PBL program customizes and individualizes the PBL experience for its students while
incorporating the research from successful PBL programs into the design and structure.
Technology is integrated into every phase to enable students to progress and complete PBL
projects successfully while learning life skills.
MIDDLE SCHOOL
Language Arts
Level I
Level I is a short term project that targets 21st century skills within the context of the
curriculum.
Middle school ELA students will complete at least one PBL project in class each semester.
Some of the major features of the Level I PBL projects are outlined below:
● The projects are based on the standards covered within the context of the curriculum
as described by the scope and sequence of the course.
● The projects are conducted as in-class group projects. Student groups of 3-4
students are recommended.
● The time required for completion of projects should be no more than one week.
● PBL teacher guides and training for effective planning and integration of the PBL
projects into the curriculum will be provided at the start of the school year.
● The teachers will provide relevant information, timelines, documents, assessment
rubrics and guidance for the successful completion of projects to their students in a
timely manner.
● Upon completion of project, students are expected to produce a three dimensional
display as well as a digital presentation of their work.
● The respective teachers using provided rubrics will complete project assessment in
each of the core content areas.
Mathematics
Level I
Level I Mathematics PBLs are embedded into the math curriculum as an introduction or
enrichment activity. The activities require group work and teachers’ special attention when
monitoring students. Once students finish working in groups, teachers should pick different
solution and organizing methods of students and let them to present in the class. The utmost
goal of the teacher is to relate different solution methods and tie all the work done to the
objectives of that curriculum unit. All of the projects are aligned with Texas Essential
Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) and they are implemented in the class. With this activities,
students improve their group work skills and their ability to explain and justify their solutions.
Science
Level I
Level I investigations are curriculum based learning experiences that are essential activities in
the course. These activities are part of the lesson; usually the “Elaborate” phase of a lesson
designed according to the 5E Instructional model. Within the context of Level I, the students
learn how to plan an investigation, implement it, analyze data and report/present their
findings and conclusions. Additionally, students learn how to collaborate, engage in
self-evaluation and work as responsible citizens in the classroom.
No additional work is required of the teacher other than to monitor and guide students
towards successful learning outcomes. These activities will be completed in class during the
school year according to the scope and sequence of the course. Since these activities are
meant to serve as a spark to student inquiry, student presentations and discussion of
conclusions on real life applications must be an integral part of classroom instruction.
Level II
These are semester-long projects that students begin during the first quarter of the course
and complete by the end of the first semester. The projects conform to all attributes of
Project Based Learning described in the information section earlier. Students will complete
the Level II project in addition to the curriculum based Level I investigations. Level II
projects should provide opportunities for the students to engage in meaningful inquiry of
personal interest at greater depth.
Students who have a difficult time coming up with project ideas and driving questions on
their own, may receive help from the teacher with such ideas. The classroom “explore” and
“engineering connections” activities, as well as the Level I projects, scaffold students into
the first phase of a project. They provide a choice of thought provoking activities that will
allow the students to generate driving questions which they can investigate on their own.
However, with Level II, students will be asked to create and develop their project from start
to finish on their own, or with a partner, and with some support from the teacher.
In Level I, the teacher provides the time, space, and supervision for the student to complete
the laboratory activities. In level II, the teacher will provide structure via checkpoint
deadlines for work increments. In both Levels I and II, the teacher guides and mentors the
students in a timely manner through various phases of the project. The timeline will aid the
student as well as the teacher in keeping track of time and will allow for efficient completion
without unnecessary stress at the end of the year.
Social Studies
Level 1
Level I projects will be drawn from the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) for a
course of study. Driving Questions are used to capture the theme of the project in the form
of a problem or a question that cannot be easily solved or answered. The Driving Question
has three main characteristics. It must be (1) provocative or challenging, (2) open-ended
and/or complex and (3) linked to the core of what students are to learn.
Examples of Driving Questions derived from TEKS of six social studies courses:
World Cultures TEKS Geography 4B: “patterns of populations in places and regions” Driving
Question: What effect will the new Exxon-Mobil corporate offices have on The Woodlands?
Texas History TEKS History 3A: “trace the development of events that led to the Texas
Revolution” Driving Question: Could Mexico have avoided the revolution in Texas?
U.S. History/8
th Grade TEKS History 5C: “explain the origin and development of American
political parties” Driving Question: How did political parties evolve into to dominant
ideologies?
World Geography TEKS Culture 18D: “compare life in a variety of urban and rural areas in the
world to evaluate political, economic, social and environmental changes” Driving Question:
What distinctions can be drawn between Brazil and Houston on changes to the urban
environment?
World History TEKS History 1E: “identify major causes and describe the major effects of
important turning points in world history from 1750-1914...the Scientific Revolution... Driving
Question: What were some effects of the Scientific Revolution in the 16
th century on
Western Culture?
U.S. History/11 TEKS History 3C: “analyze social issues affecting women, minorities, children,
immigrants, urbanization, the Social Gospel, and philanthropy of industrialists” (1877-1898)
Driving Question: Were industrial philanthropists of the late 1800s robber barons or
generous benefactors?
Technology Integration
Email System and Chromebooks:
● All middle school students will be provided an email account through Harmony’s Gmail
domain.
● The choice of Gmail account will allow students to use their Chromebooks for PBL
reports and digital presentations without any problems.
Level I
● Upon completion of PBL projects in Math and Science, students will be required to
produce a digital story involving photos and captions only (digital photo gallery
presentation).
● Producing digital photo gallery presentations in Social Studies and English subjects will
be optional.
● Digital presentations will be evaluated via rubrics for technology and content
● Students may use software such as Windows Movie Maker, animoto, iVideo or
WeVideo. WeVideo is recommended as the software tool for creating PBL digital photo
gallery presentations based on following factors: ease of use; seamless integration of
WeVideo with Gmail, Google Drive, and thus Chromebooks; and internet-based
software without the need of installation or physical storage space needs.
● Training materials including video tutorials are prepared for students and teachers at
this level. The training materials are on how to use WeVideo for creating digital photo
gallery presentations. The video tutorials are also hosted through pbl.harmonytx.org
website. Produced digital photo gallery presentations may be kept in students’ Google
Drive folders for future reference.
Level II
● Students will complete one interdisciplinary PBL project during the first semester of an
academic year, and which they will use as their Science Fair submission. Upon
completion of the PBL project, students will be required to produce a digital story with
pictures, and sound (narration).
● Digital presentations will be evaluated via rubrics for technology and content
● Students may use software such as Windows Movie Maker, animoto, iVideo or
WeVideo. WeVideo is recommended as the software tool for creating PBL digital photo
gallery presentations based on following factors: ease of use; seamless integration of
WeVideo with Gmail, Google Drive, and thus Chromebooks; and internet-based
software without the need of installation or physical storage space needs.
● Training materials including video tutorials are for students and teachers at this level.
The training materials will be on how to use WeVideo for creating digital stories.
● The video tutorials will be hosted through the pbl.harmonytx.org website.
● Harmony Students’ digital stories, based on their Level II PBL projects, may also be
submitted to the annual Digital Storytelling Contest (DISTCO), and will be accepted
automatically.
● The DISTCO system will host students’ PBL digital stories for future review and
access.
HIGH SCHOOL
Chemistry
Level I
Chemistry Level I investigations are curriculum based learning experiences that are essential
activities in the course. These activities may be part of the lesson; usually the “Elaborate”
phase of a lesson designed according to the 5E Instructional model. Within the context of
Level I, the students learn how to plan an investigation, implement it, analyze data and
report/present their findings and conclusions. Additionally, the students learn how to
collaborate, engage in self-evaluation and to work as responsible citizens in the classroom.
These investigations may serve as an “entry event” for a student to design a long-term Level
III project.
No additional work is required of the teacher other than to monitor and guide students
towards successful learning outcomes. These activities will be completed in class during the
school year according to the scope and sequence of the course. The essential activities
identified for the chemistry course are –
• Thickness of an oil film
• Percent of salt in sea sand
1. Empirical formula
2. Percent yield of a chemical reaction
3. Heat of reaction
4. Acid rain
Since these activities may serve as a spark to student inquiry, student presentations and
discussion of real life applications must be an integral part of classroom instruction.
Level II & Level III
These are semester-long projects that students begin during the first quarter of the course
and complete by the end of the first semester. The projects conform to all attributes of
Project Based Learning described in the information section earlier. Students will complete
either a Level II or Level III project in addition to the curriculum based Level I investigations.
Level II and Level III projects provide opportunities for the students to engage in meaningful
inquiry of personal interest at greater depth.
Level II is intended for students who have a difficult time coming up with project ideas and
driving questions on their own. Level II scaffolds students into the first phase of the project
by providing a choice of thought provoking activities that will allow the students to generate
driving questions that they can investigate on their own. Level III applies to students who
create and develop their project from start to finish on their own with little support from the
teacher.
In Level II, the teacher provides the list of “Study” activities for student selection and also
provides the time, space, and supervision for the student to complete the laboratory
activities. In both Levels II and III, the teacher guides and mentors the students in a timely
manner through various phases of the project. The timeline will aid the student as well as the
teacher in keeping track of time and allows for efficient completion without unnecessary
stress at the end of the year.
Biology
Level I
Biology Level I projects are aligned with the TEKS and follows the Scope and Sequence.
Students will complete four level I PBL projects in class through each 9 weeks period.
Following PBL investigations will be done in class:
○ Lactase Enzyme
○ Diffusion and Osmosis
○ Blood Typing and Genetics
○ Antibiotic Sensitivity Test
Level II & III
Biology Level II and Level III are semester-long individual projects that students begin during
the first quarter of the course and complete by the end of the first semester. The projects
conform to all attributes of Project Based Learning described in the information section
earlier. Students will complete either a Level II or Level III project in addition to the
curriculum based Level I investigations. Level II and Level III projects provide opportunities
for the students to engage in meaningful inquiry of personal interest at greater depth.
Level II is intended for students who have a difficult time coming up with project ideas and
driving questions on their own. Level II scaffolds students into the first phase of the project
by providing a choice of thought provoking activities that will allow the students to generate
driving questions that they can investigate on their own. Following categories are available
for Level II Biology projects.
● Biomolecules and food
● Biotechnology
● Cell Respiration
● Cells
● Classification
● Diffusion
● DNA
● Enzymes
● Genetics
● Heart
● Homeostasis
● Lungs
● Mitosis
● Meiosis
● Osmosis
● Photosynthesis
● Pill Bug Behavior
● Proteins
● Starch Reserve
● Viruses
In Level II, the teacher provides the list of “Study” activities for student selection and also
provides the time, space, and supervision for the student to complete the laboratory
activities. In both Levels II and III, the teacher guides and mentors the students in a timely
manner through various phases of the project. The timeline will aid the student as well as the
teacher in keeping track of time and allows for efficient completion without unnecessary
stress at the end of the semester.
Level III applies to students who create and develop their project from start to finish on their
own with little support from the teacher. In this level, students are responsible for finding
their own project ideas. For example, they might work on a research project by collaborating
with a university professor or other outside mentors. Level III will be very similar to Science
Fair Project.
Physics
Level I
Physics Level I investigations are curriculum based learning experiences that are
essential activities in the course. These activities may be part of the lesson; usually the
“Elaborate” phase of a lesson designed according to the 5E Instructional model. Within the
context of Level I, the students learn how to plan an investigation, implement it, analyze
data and report/present their findings and conclusions. Additionally, the students learn how
to collaborate, engage in self- evaluation and to work as responsible citizens in the
classroom. These investigations may serve as an “entry event” for a student to design a
long-term Level III project.
No additional work is required of the teacher other than to monitor and guide students
towards successful learning outcomes. These activities will be completed in class during the
school year according to the scope and sequence of the course. The essential activities
identified for the physics course in each quarter;
1. Distance vs. Displacement with Graph matching extended activity.
2. Impulse Momentum relation in a an elastic collision of PAScars
3. Ohms law in serial and parallel DC circuits
4. Calculating the index of refraction by Snell’s Law
Since these activities may serve as a spark to student inquiry, student presentations
and discussion of real life applications must be an integral part of classroom instruction.
Level II & III
Level II and Level III are semester-long individual projects that students begin during
the first quarter of the course and complete by the end of the semester. The projects
conform to all attributes of Project Based Learning described in the information section
earlier. Students will complete either a Level II or Level III project in addition to the
curriculum based Level I investigations. Level II and Level III projects provide opportunities
for the students to engage in meaningful inquiry of personal interest at greater depth.
Level II is intended for students who have a difficult time coming up with project
ideas and driving questions on their own. Level II scaffolds students into the first phase of
the project by providing a choice of thought provoking activities that will allow the students
to generate driving questions that they can investigate on their own. Level III applies to
students who create and develop their project from start to finish on their own with little
support from the teacher.
In Level II, the teacher provides the list of “Study” activities for student selection
and also provides the time, space, and supervision for the student to complete the
laboratory activities. In both Levels II and III, the teacher guides and mentors the students
in a timely manner through various phases of the project. The timeline will aid the student as
well as the teacher in keeping track of time and allows for efficient completion without
unnecessary stress at the end of the semester.
There is no certain list or handouts for level III. The teacher may prepare a set of
project ideas for you to choose, or the students may come with their PBL project idea and
driven question which covers the subjects you will learn from math or science classes. It can
be :
· in an investigation format
· in a science research project format
· in an engineering or technology project format
Participating in an academic science contest( Robotics , Science Olympiad, ..etc) may be
counted as PBL Level- 3 project.
Mathematics
Level I
Level I Mathematics PBLs are embedded into the math curriculum as an introduction or
enrichment activity. The activities require group work and teachers’ special attention when
monitoring students. Once students finish working in groups, teachers should pick different
solution and organizing methods of students and let them to present in the class. The utmost
goal of the teacher is to relate different solution methods and tie all the work done to the
objectives of that curriculum unit. All of the projects are aligned with Texas Essential
Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) and they are implemented in the class. With this activities,
students improve their group work skills and their ability to explain and justify their solutions.
Level II & III
Level II Mathematics PBLs are semester-long projects. Students will pick the topic from a
given list of the projects along with the instruction, helpful sites and reflection questions.
Students will begin the project at the beginning of the academic year and submit it at the
end. Teacher will support the student during the year. Teacher will ask each student to
submit a timeline to finish the project, therefore students do not have to rush at the end.
Teachers will check students’ progress and give feedback throughout the year. These
projects require construction, data collection and analyses, presentation of the findings and
reflection on the project. Each project comes with the reflection questions that students
have to answer once they finish their projects. Students have to submit the answers of the
reflection questions along with the product they have worked on (poster, research report,
construction of an objects etc.). The projects are directly intended to apply mathematics in
real life. Therefore, students will recognize the use of mathematics upon the completion of
their projects.
There is no certain list or handouts for level III. The teacher may prepare a set of project
ideas for you to choose, or the students may come with their PBL project idea and driven
question which covers the subjects you will learn from math or science classes.
English/Language Arts
Level I
The instructional model at Harmony is guided through the lens of Project Based Learning
(PBL). Instruction has moved from short term knowledge retention to long term retention by
integrating 21st Century learning experiences and embedding Texas Essential Knowledge and
Skills (TEKS) such as listening, speaking, reading, and writing as well as citizenship . These
real life experiences will prepare Harmony students for future expectations of our society and
workforce. The goal is to promote not only collaboration skills and student ownership of
learning but also to promote student success in state and national standards.
Level II & II
Level II projects are the year-long individual math or science projects that students begin
during the first quarter of the course and complete by the end of the course. Students will
complete the Level II project, including its cross-curricular requirements, in addition to the
curriculum based Level I investigations.
Level II projects should provide opportunities for the students to engage in meaningful inquiry
of personal interest at greater depth by creating and developing their own driving questions
and projects, with some support from the teacher.
Students will select one of the following options (journal, argumentative essay, narrative
essay, newspaper, or interview) to complete during the process of developing their Level II
project, or will obtain ELA teacher-permission to pursue a different option.
This ELA piece will be assessed with a common rubric. Specific deadlines will be determined
by the ELA teacher.
Social Studies
At the High School level, students will have two PBL projects to complete each year (One per
Semester) at level 1, as well as several Social Studies components to be include in the level
II and III PBL projects.
Some examples of the driving questions at this level are:
World Geography TEKS Culture 18D: “compare life in a variety of urban and rural areas in the
world to evaluate political, economic, social and environmental changes”
Driving Question: What distinctions can be drawn between Brazil and Houston on changes
to the urban environment?
World History TEKS History 1E: “identify major causes and describe the major effects of
important turning points in world history from 1750-1914...the Scientific Revolution
Driving Question: What were some effects of the Scientific Revolution in the 16
th century
on Western Culture?
U.S. History/11 TEKS History 3C: “analyze social issues affecting women, minorities, children,
immigrants, urbanization, the Social Gospel, and philanthropy of industrialists” (1877-1898)
Driving Question: Were industrial philanthropists of the late 1800s robber barons or
generous benefactors?
Level II & III
Level II & III PBLs in high school are Math/Science projects with integrated English and Social
studies components. Students in grades 9 – 12 will be asked to choose a driving question
from their Math or Science course. It is then up to the student to investigate the
connections the project has to social studies issues. The selection of a driving question and
the social studies connections should be determined by the conclusion of the first quarter.
Below are 6 ways a student can find the social studies connections to their level II and III
PBLs.
1. Historical Connection: Students should be encouraged to examine the historical
connections to a math or science problem. They can do this by exploring an event in the
past that might be related to the discovery, or an effect of the discovery on an event that
had happened as a result. For example, if a student is investigating air presser, they can
include how air pressure is related to the discovery of flight. (From the discovery of hot air
balloons in the 18
th
century, all the way through space travel).
2. Economic Influence: Students can connect a scientific discovery with its economic
impact. For example they can explain the discovery of radio waves, and the impact that has
had on business and trade. Or explain how a new product has revolutionized an industry (GM
Foods) or has caused the destruction of an existing economy.
3. Political influence: Students could investigate the role politics plays in there topic of
choice. They can trace the influence governments have on funding particular research
programs or how much funding is directed towards developing new scientists. Conversely,
students could explore how science influences politics, such as the discovery of
“greenhouse gases”.
4. Geographical influence: Students can look at how their topic can be observed in the
natural world, and investigate if geography is an influence. As volcanos, geysers and
hurricanes all have geographical influences students can make these connections and explain
how these forces can affect all of us.
5. Effect of change on Society: Students can show how the topic of their project has
influenced the way we live. Students investigating the development of computers, and show
how this technology has revolutionized our whole world. Or how discoveries in the medical
fields have changed the life expectancy, and what impact this has on culture.
6. Legal impact: Students can also look at how scientific and mathematical discoveries
have impacted our legal system. The discovery of Steam power directly led to the Gibbons
Vs. Ogden Supreme court case which decided several aspects of federal power in the United
States.
Technology Integration
Email System and Chromebooks:
● All HS school students will be provided an email account through Harmony’s Gmail
domain.
● The choice of Gmail account will allow students to use their Chromebooks for PBL
reports and digital presentations without any problems.
● All high school students will sign up for an additional email account through Gmail
domain.Students will use the Google Sites and Youtube Channels through their gmail
account.
● Students will obtain personal Google account that can be solely used for PBL
assignments
● The Gmail system ,Google sites, Google docs ,YouTube Channels, Google Plus and
PICASA albums may not be used to create any offensive or disruptive messages.
Among those which are considered offensive are any messages that contain sexual
implications, racial or gender-specific slurs, or any other comment that offensively
addresses an individual’s age, sexual orientation, religious or political beliefs, national
origin, disability, or anything that could be construed as harassment or disparaging of
others.
● Students may not use e-mail or Google sites to send, receive or post materials,
proprietary financial information, or other similar materials that violate copyright law.
Students will be responsible for any content in their Google personal site that violates
copyright law.
Level I
● In each core subject, English, Math, Social Studies, and Science, students will
complete two PBL projects in each semester.Upon completion of PBL projects in Math
and Science, students will be required to produce a digital story involving photos and
captions only (digital photo gallery presentation).
● Producing digital photo gallery presentations in Social Studies and English subjects will
be optional.
● There is a Technology Rubric for evaluation of PBL digital photo gallery presentations
at this level.
● WeVideo was selected as software tool for creating PBL digital photo gallery
presentations at this level. This decision was based on following factors: The ease of
use, seamless integration of WeVideo with Gmail and Google Drive, being an
internet-based software without the need of installation, and the ability to work with
Chromebooks.
● Training materials including video tutorials will be supplied for students and teachers
at this level. The training materials will be on how to use WeVideo for creating digital
photo gallery presentations. The video tutorials will be hosted through
pbl.harmonytx.org website.
● Produced digital photo gallery presentations will be kept in students’ Google Drive
folders for future reference.
Level II & III
● Students will complete one interdisciplinary PBL project during the academic year.
Upon completion of the PBL project, students will be required to produce;
● a digital story complete with pictures, video, sound and narration.
● a google site explaining their projects
● a brochure for their project including QR codes for movie and website link.
● Students will post their movie presentation to their YouTube Channel.
● Both movie and handout will be inserted in student’s Google Site.
● There is a Technology Rubric for the evaluation of PBL digital stories at this level.
● WeVideo will be recommended as the software tool for creating PBL digital stories at
this level. However, students will have a choice to select from other digital
storytelling software such as Photostory 3, iMovie, Animoto, and Windows Live Movie
Maker.
● Training materials including video tutorials are prepared for students and teachers at
this level. The training materials will be on how to use WeVideo and other popular
software for creating digital stories. The video tutorials will be hosted through
pbl.harmonytx.org website.
● Harmony Students’ PBL digital stories will be accepted to the Digital Storytelling
Contest (DISTCO) 2014 automatically.
● DISTCO system will host students’ PBL digital stories for future review and access.
the increased need for students to acquire critical-thinking, problem-solving, collaboration
and communication skills, otherwise know as 21st century skills. Through Project Based
Learning (PBL), students are exposed to deep learning experiences that are inquiry based,
student-centered, and integrated to the curriculum. The Harmony approach is to maintain
the focus on standards-based and student-centered teaching while enriching and extending
the learning of students through PBL work. The goal is to promote not only collaborative skills
and student ownership of learning but also to promote student success in state and national
standards.
What is Project-Based Learning?
Project Based Learning is an instructional approach that emphasizes critical-thinking,
collaboration and personalized learning. In project-based learning, student groups engage in
meaningful inquiry that is of personal interest to them. These projects are based on problems
which are real-life oriented, curriculum-based, and often interdisciplinary. Learners decide
how to approach a problem and what activities or processes they will perform. They collect
information from a variety of sources, analyze, synthesize and derive understanding from it.
The real-world focus of PBL activities is central to the process because it motivates students
and adds value to their work. Their learning is connected to something real and involves life
skills such as collaboration and reflection. Technology enables students and teachers in
various phases of the PBL process. At the end of the PBL, students demonstrate their newly
acquired knowledge and are evaluated by how much they have learned and how well they
communicate it. Students also conduct self-evaluation to assess their own growth and
learning. Throughout this process, the teacher's role is to guide and advise students, rather
than to direct and manage student work.
What are the components of Project-Based Learning?
According to the Buck Institute for Education there are eight essential components of
meaningful PBL experiences. These essentials are summarized below.
1. Significant content: The project focuses on important knowledge and concepts derived
from the standards and targets essential understanding in the course. Students should find
the content to be significant in terms of their own lives and interests. A well designed PBL is
an effective vehicle for understanding content more deeply than by traditional methods such
as lectures and textbooks.
2. A Need to Know: Teachers powerfully activate students’ need to know content by
launching a project with an “entry event” that engages student interest and initiates
questioning. The entry event can be anything that sparks student inquiry such as a video, a
discussion, a guest speaker, a field trip, a laboratory experience, etc. In contrast,
announcing a project with a packet of papers will likely not create excitement and an
atmosphere of active learning. Simply telling students that they should learn something
because they will need it later does not motivate them. With a compelling student project,
the reason for learning relevant material becomes personal and purposeful to the student.
3. A Driving Question: After the discussion and brainstorming, students create a Driving
Question to focus their efforts. A good Driving Question captures the heart of the project in
clear, compelling language. The Question should be provocative, open-ended, complex, and
linked to the core of what we want students to learn. It could be abstract, concrete, or
focused on solving a problem. The Driving Question allows students to understand why they
are undertaking a project as well as the sequence of activities that ensues from their
personal challenge.
4. Student Choice and Voice: Students’ interest is captured by a challenging question that
is selected and crafted by the students. This provides the student Choice to the project.
The requirements of the projects such as project report, digital and oral presentations, visual
demonstrations etc. provide Student Voice to the project. The Student Choice and Voice
makes the project meaningful to the students. The more Voice and Choice for the student,
the greater the ownership of the learning will be. However, projects should be designed with
the extent of student choice that best fits each student. On the limited-choice end of the
scale, learners can select what topic to study or choose how to design, create, and present
products. As a middle ground, teachers might provide a limited menu of options to prevent
students from becoming overwhelmed by choices. On the “the more the better” end of the
scale, students can decide what product they will create, what resources they will use, how
they will structure their time or even their topic and Driving Question.
5. 21st Century Skills: Collaboration is central to the PBL learning experience. A project
should give students opportunities to build valuable 21st century skills such as collaboration,
communication, critical thinking, and the use of technology, which will serve them well in the
workplace and in life. Once students have decided on the Driving Question, they form teams
of three or four and begin planning how they would work together. Each team regularly
pauses to review their progress. Teachers can help grow these collaboration skills by using
team building techniques and time/task organizers. Teachers in a Project Based Learning
environment also assess these skills and provide frequent opportunities for students to
assess themselves.
6. Inquiry and Innovation: Brainstorming sessions as a class helps students generate new
ideas and questions. Student team discussion allows opportunities to fine-tune their own
Driving Questions and to discuss resources and procedures. Students find project work to be
more meaningful if they conduct real inquiry that begins with their own questions, leads to a
search for resources and the discovery of answers, and which ultimately leads to generating
new questions, testing ideas, and drawing their own conclusions. With real inquiry comes
innovation – a new answer to a Driving Question, a new product, a new solution to a
problem. Students are not expected to simply reproduce provided information in a pretty
format. The teacher’s task is to create the context for real inquiry in the classroom and to
guide students through the process.
7. Feedback and Revision: As students develop their ideas and products, student teams
use rubrics and exemplars to review and critique one another’s work. The teacher checks
research notes, reviews rough drafts and plans, and meets with teams to monitor their
progress. The mentoring process of monitoring and feedback is formalized and structured so
all student teams have guidance from their teacher throughout the duration of the project.
Students learn through this mentoring that first attempts do not always result in high quality
and that revisions are a frequent feature of real-world work. In addition to providing direct
feedback, a teacher coaches students in using rubrics or other sets of criteria to critique one
another’s work. Teachers can arrange for experts or adult mentors to provide feedback,
which is especially meaningful to students because of the source.
8. Publicly Presented Product: Student teams present their findings, conclusions, and
solutions to audiences such as peers, parents, representatives of community, business,
government organizations and professionals from various industries. Students answer
questions and reflect on how they completed the project, next steps they might take, and
what they gained in terms of knowledge and skills and pride. When they present their work to
a real audience, they connect to real life through their PBL projects. These projects become
authentic when the process replicates real-life tasks and students are no longer observers
but participants in real life experiences.
What is Standards-Focused PBL?
There is no one accepted definition of PBL. However, BIE defines standards-focused PBL as
a systematic teaching method that engages students in learning knowledge and skills
through an extended inquiry process structured around complex, authentic questions
and carefully designed products and tasks. This definition encompasses a spectrum
ranging from brief projects of one to two weeks based on a single subject in one classroom
to year long, interdisciplinary projects that involve community participation and adults
outside the school.
More important than the definition itself are the attributes of effective projects. You will find
that the BIE planning model is based on a number of criteria that distinguish carefully planned
projects from other extended activities in the classroom.
Outstanding projects...
● Recognize students’ inherent drive to learn, their capability to do important work, and
their need to be taken seriously by putting them at the center of the learning
process.
● Engage students in the central concepts and principles of a discipline. The project
work is central rather than peripheral to the curriculum.
● Highlight provocative issues or questions that lead students to in-depth exploration of
authentic and important topics.
● Require the use of essential tools and skills, including technology, for learning,
self-management, and project management.
● Specify products that solve problems, explain dilemmas, or present information
generated through investigation, research, or reasoning.
● Include multiple products that permit frequent feedback and consistent opportunities
for student to learn from experience.
● Use performance-based assessments that communicate high expectations, present
rigorous challenges, and require a range of skills and knowledge.
● Encourage collaboration in some form, either through small groups, student-led
presentation, or whole-class evaluations of project results.
The BIE model for PBL also addresses a singular need in the field of PBL: to create
standards-focused projects that fit well with the era of accountability and performance.
Often projects have been used as fun or change-of-pace events completed after students
have been pushed through homework assignments, lectures, and tests.
In standards-based PBL, students are pulled through the curriculum by a Driving
Question or authentic problem that creates a need to know the material. The Driving
Question is tied to content standards in the curriculum, and assessment is explicitly designed
to evaluate the students’ knowledge of the content.
Similarly, Project Based Learning is sometimes equated with inquiry-based or experiential
learning. Though PBL shares some overlapping characteristics with these two terms,
standards-focused PBL is designed to acknowledge the importance of standards and
evaluation of student learning. In an era of accountability, with testing and performance
uppermost in the minds of parents and educators, it is imperative that all instructional
methods incorporate high standards, rigorous challenges, and valid assessment methods.
References
Solomon, G. (2003). Project-Based Learning: a Primer. Retrieved from
http://www.techlearning.com/db_area/archives/TL/2003/01/project.php
Grant, M. (2002). Getting a grip on Project-Based Learning: Theory, Cases and
Recommendations. Retrieved from http://www.ncsu.edu/meridian/win2002/514
Larmer, J., Mergendoller, J. (2010). 8 Essentials for Project-Based Learning. Retrieved from
http://www.bie.org/tools/freebies/Project Based Learning for the 21st Century
Markham, Thom, John Larmer, and Jason Louis. Ravitz. Project Based Learning Handbook: A
Guide to Standards-focused Project Based Learning for Middle and High School Teachers.
Novato, CA: Buck Institute for Education, 2003. Print.
How does Project Based Learning look like at Harmony Schools?
Harmony PBL program customizes and individualizes the PBL experience for its students while
incorporating the research from successful PBL programs into the design and structure.
Technology is integrated into every phase to enable students to progress and complete PBL
projects successfully while learning life skills.
MIDDLE SCHOOL
Language Arts
Level I
Level I is a short term project that targets 21st century skills within the context of the
curriculum.
Middle school ELA students will complete at least one PBL project in class each semester.
Some of the major features of the Level I PBL projects are outlined below:
● The projects are based on the standards covered within the context of the curriculum
as described by the scope and sequence of the course.
● The projects are conducted as in-class group projects. Student groups of 3-4
students are recommended.
● The time required for completion of projects should be no more than one week.
● PBL teacher guides and training for effective planning and integration of the PBL
projects into the curriculum will be provided at the start of the school year.
● The teachers will provide relevant information, timelines, documents, assessment
rubrics and guidance for the successful completion of projects to their students in a
timely manner.
● Upon completion of project, students are expected to produce a three dimensional
display as well as a digital presentation of their work.
● The respective teachers using provided rubrics will complete project assessment in
each of the core content areas.
Mathematics
Level I
Level I Mathematics PBLs are embedded into the math curriculum as an introduction or
enrichment activity. The activities require group work and teachers’ special attention when
monitoring students. Once students finish working in groups, teachers should pick different
solution and organizing methods of students and let them to present in the class. The utmost
goal of the teacher is to relate different solution methods and tie all the work done to the
objectives of that curriculum unit. All of the projects are aligned with Texas Essential
Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) and they are implemented in the class. With this activities,
students improve their group work skills and their ability to explain and justify their solutions.
Science
Level I
Level I investigations are curriculum based learning experiences that are essential activities in
the course. These activities are part of the lesson; usually the “Elaborate” phase of a lesson
designed according to the 5E Instructional model. Within the context of Level I, the students
learn how to plan an investigation, implement it, analyze data and report/present their
findings and conclusions. Additionally, students learn how to collaborate, engage in
self-evaluation and work as responsible citizens in the classroom.
No additional work is required of the teacher other than to monitor and guide students
towards successful learning outcomes. These activities will be completed in class during the
school year according to the scope and sequence of the course. Since these activities are
meant to serve as a spark to student inquiry, student presentations and discussion of
conclusions on real life applications must be an integral part of classroom instruction.
Level II
These are semester-long projects that students begin during the first quarter of the course
and complete by the end of the first semester. The projects conform to all attributes of
Project Based Learning described in the information section earlier. Students will complete
the Level II project in addition to the curriculum based Level I investigations. Level II
projects should provide opportunities for the students to engage in meaningful inquiry of
personal interest at greater depth.
Students who have a difficult time coming up with project ideas and driving questions on
their own, may receive help from the teacher with such ideas. The classroom “explore” and
“engineering connections” activities, as well as the Level I projects, scaffold students into
the first phase of a project. They provide a choice of thought provoking activities that will
allow the students to generate driving questions which they can investigate on their own.
However, with Level II, students will be asked to create and develop their project from start
to finish on their own, or with a partner, and with some support from the teacher.
In Level I, the teacher provides the time, space, and supervision for the student to complete
the laboratory activities. In level II, the teacher will provide structure via checkpoint
deadlines for work increments. In both Levels I and II, the teacher guides and mentors the
students in a timely manner through various phases of the project. The timeline will aid the
student as well as the teacher in keeping track of time and will allow for efficient completion
without unnecessary stress at the end of the year.
Social Studies
Level 1
Level I projects will be drawn from the Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) for a
course of study. Driving Questions are used to capture the theme of the project in the form
of a problem or a question that cannot be easily solved or answered. The Driving Question
has three main characteristics. It must be (1) provocative or challenging, (2) open-ended
and/or complex and (3) linked to the core of what students are to learn.
Examples of Driving Questions derived from TEKS of six social studies courses:
World Cultures TEKS Geography 4B: “patterns of populations in places and regions” Driving
Question: What effect will the new Exxon-Mobil corporate offices have on The Woodlands?
Texas History TEKS History 3A: “trace the development of events that led to the Texas
Revolution” Driving Question: Could Mexico have avoided the revolution in Texas?
U.S. History/8
th Grade TEKS History 5C: “explain the origin and development of American
political parties” Driving Question: How did political parties evolve into to dominant
ideologies?
World Geography TEKS Culture 18D: “compare life in a variety of urban and rural areas in the
world to evaluate political, economic, social and environmental changes” Driving Question:
What distinctions can be drawn between Brazil and Houston on changes to the urban
environment?
World History TEKS History 1E: “identify major causes and describe the major effects of
important turning points in world history from 1750-1914...the Scientific Revolution... Driving
Question: What were some effects of the Scientific Revolution in the 16
th century on
Western Culture?
U.S. History/11 TEKS History 3C: “analyze social issues affecting women, minorities, children,
immigrants, urbanization, the Social Gospel, and philanthropy of industrialists” (1877-1898)
Driving Question: Were industrial philanthropists of the late 1800s robber barons or
generous benefactors?
Technology Integration
Email System and Chromebooks:
● All middle school students will be provided an email account through Harmony’s Gmail
domain.
● The choice of Gmail account will allow students to use their Chromebooks for PBL
reports and digital presentations without any problems.
Level I
● Upon completion of PBL projects in Math and Science, students will be required to
produce a digital story involving photos and captions only (digital photo gallery
presentation).
● Producing digital photo gallery presentations in Social Studies and English subjects will
be optional.
● Digital presentations will be evaluated via rubrics for technology and content
● Students may use software such as Windows Movie Maker, animoto, iVideo or
WeVideo. WeVideo is recommended as the software tool for creating PBL digital photo
gallery presentations based on following factors: ease of use; seamless integration of
WeVideo with Gmail, Google Drive, and thus Chromebooks; and internet-based
software without the need of installation or physical storage space needs.
● Training materials including video tutorials are prepared for students and teachers at
this level. The training materials are on how to use WeVideo for creating digital photo
gallery presentations. The video tutorials are also hosted through pbl.harmonytx.org
website. Produced digital photo gallery presentations may be kept in students’ Google
Drive folders for future reference.
Level II
● Students will complete one interdisciplinary PBL project during the first semester of an
academic year, and which they will use as their Science Fair submission. Upon
completion of the PBL project, students will be required to produce a digital story with
pictures, and sound (narration).
● Digital presentations will be evaluated via rubrics for technology and content
● Students may use software such as Windows Movie Maker, animoto, iVideo or
WeVideo. WeVideo is recommended as the software tool for creating PBL digital photo
gallery presentations based on following factors: ease of use; seamless integration of
WeVideo with Gmail, Google Drive, and thus Chromebooks; and internet-based
software without the need of installation or physical storage space needs.
● Training materials including video tutorials are for students and teachers at this level.
The training materials will be on how to use WeVideo for creating digital stories.
● The video tutorials will be hosted through the pbl.harmonytx.org website.
● Harmony Students’ digital stories, based on their Level II PBL projects, may also be
submitted to the annual Digital Storytelling Contest (DISTCO), and will be accepted
automatically.
● The DISTCO system will host students’ PBL digital stories for future review and
access.
HIGH SCHOOL
Chemistry
Level I
Chemistry Level I investigations are curriculum based learning experiences that are essential
activities in the course. These activities may be part of the lesson; usually the “Elaborate”
phase of a lesson designed according to the 5E Instructional model. Within the context of
Level I, the students learn how to plan an investigation, implement it, analyze data and
report/present their findings and conclusions. Additionally, the students learn how to
collaborate, engage in self-evaluation and to work as responsible citizens in the classroom.
These investigations may serve as an “entry event” for a student to design a long-term Level
III project.
No additional work is required of the teacher other than to monitor and guide students
towards successful learning outcomes. These activities will be completed in class during the
school year according to the scope and sequence of the course. The essential activities
identified for the chemistry course are –
• Thickness of an oil film
• Percent of salt in sea sand
1. Empirical formula
2. Percent yield of a chemical reaction
3. Heat of reaction
4. Acid rain
Since these activities may serve as a spark to student inquiry, student presentations and
discussion of real life applications must be an integral part of classroom instruction.
Level II & Level III
These are semester-long projects that students begin during the first quarter of the course
and complete by the end of the first semester. The projects conform to all attributes of
Project Based Learning described in the information section earlier. Students will complete
either a Level II or Level III project in addition to the curriculum based Level I investigations.
Level II and Level III projects provide opportunities for the students to engage in meaningful
inquiry of personal interest at greater depth.
Level II is intended for students who have a difficult time coming up with project ideas and
driving questions on their own. Level II scaffolds students into the first phase of the project
by providing a choice of thought provoking activities that will allow the students to generate
driving questions that they can investigate on their own. Level III applies to students who
create and develop their project from start to finish on their own with little support from the
teacher.
In Level II, the teacher provides the list of “Study” activities for student selection and also
provides the time, space, and supervision for the student to complete the laboratory
activities. In both Levels II and III, the teacher guides and mentors the students in a timely
manner through various phases of the project. The timeline will aid the student as well as the
teacher in keeping track of time and allows for efficient completion without unnecessary
stress at the end of the year.
Biology
Level I
Biology Level I projects are aligned with the TEKS and follows the Scope and Sequence.
Students will complete four level I PBL projects in class through each 9 weeks period.
Following PBL investigations will be done in class:
○ Lactase Enzyme
○ Diffusion and Osmosis
○ Blood Typing and Genetics
○ Antibiotic Sensitivity Test
Level II & III
Biology Level II and Level III are semester-long individual projects that students begin during
the first quarter of the course and complete by the end of the first semester. The projects
conform to all attributes of Project Based Learning described in the information section
earlier. Students will complete either a Level II or Level III project in addition to the
curriculum based Level I investigations. Level II and Level III projects provide opportunities
for the students to engage in meaningful inquiry of personal interest at greater depth.
Level II is intended for students who have a difficult time coming up with project ideas and
driving questions on their own. Level II scaffolds students into the first phase of the project
by providing a choice of thought provoking activities that will allow the students to generate
driving questions that they can investigate on their own. Following categories are available
for Level II Biology projects.
● Biomolecules and food
● Biotechnology
● Cell Respiration
● Cells
● Classification
● Diffusion
● DNA
● Enzymes
● Genetics
● Heart
● Homeostasis
● Lungs
● Mitosis
● Meiosis
● Osmosis
● Photosynthesis
● Pill Bug Behavior
● Proteins
● Starch Reserve
● Viruses
In Level II, the teacher provides the list of “Study” activities for student selection and also
provides the time, space, and supervision for the student to complete the laboratory
activities. In both Levels II and III, the teacher guides and mentors the students in a timely
manner through various phases of the project. The timeline will aid the student as well as the
teacher in keeping track of time and allows for efficient completion without unnecessary
stress at the end of the semester.
Level III applies to students who create and develop their project from start to finish on their
own with little support from the teacher. In this level, students are responsible for finding
their own project ideas. For example, they might work on a research project by collaborating
with a university professor or other outside mentors. Level III will be very similar to Science
Fair Project.
Physics
Level I
Physics Level I investigations are curriculum based learning experiences that are
essential activities in the course. These activities may be part of the lesson; usually the
“Elaborate” phase of a lesson designed according to the 5E Instructional model. Within the
context of Level I, the students learn how to plan an investigation, implement it, analyze
data and report/present their findings and conclusions. Additionally, the students learn how
to collaborate, engage in self- evaluation and to work as responsible citizens in the
classroom. These investigations may serve as an “entry event” for a student to design a
long-term Level III project.
No additional work is required of the teacher other than to monitor and guide students
towards successful learning outcomes. These activities will be completed in class during the
school year according to the scope and sequence of the course. The essential activities
identified for the physics course in each quarter;
1. Distance vs. Displacement with Graph matching extended activity.
2. Impulse Momentum relation in a an elastic collision of PAScars
3. Ohms law in serial and parallel DC circuits
4. Calculating the index of refraction by Snell’s Law
Since these activities may serve as a spark to student inquiry, student presentations
and discussion of real life applications must be an integral part of classroom instruction.
Level II & III
Level II and Level III are semester-long individual projects that students begin during
the first quarter of the course and complete by the end of the semester. The projects
conform to all attributes of Project Based Learning described in the information section
earlier. Students will complete either a Level II or Level III project in addition to the
curriculum based Level I investigations. Level II and Level III projects provide opportunities
for the students to engage in meaningful inquiry of personal interest at greater depth.
Level II is intended for students who have a difficult time coming up with project
ideas and driving questions on their own. Level II scaffolds students into the first phase of
the project by providing a choice of thought provoking activities that will allow the students
to generate driving questions that they can investigate on their own. Level III applies to
students who create and develop their project from start to finish on their own with little
support from the teacher.
In Level II, the teacher provides the list of “Study” activities for student selection
and also provides the time, space, and supervision for the student to complete the
laboratory activities. In both Levels II and III, the teacher guides and mentors the students
in a timely manner through various phases of the project. The timeline will aid the student as
well as the teacher in keeping track of time and allows for efficient completion without
unnecessary stress at the end of the semester.
There is no certain list or handouts for level III. The teacher may prepare a set of
project ideas for you to choose, or the students may come with their PBL project idea and
driven question which covers the subjects you will learn from math or science classes. It can
be :
· in an investigation format
· in a science research project format
· in an engineering or technology project format
Participating in an academic science contest( Robotics , Science Olympiad, ..etc) may be
counted as PBL Level- 3 project.
Mathematics
Level I
Level I Mathematics PBLs are embedded into the math curriculum as an introduction or
enrichment activity. The activities require group work and teachers’ special attention when
monitoring students. Once students finish working in groups, teachers should pick different
solution and organizing methods of students and let them to present in the class. The utmost
goal of the teacher is to relate different solution methods and tie all the work done to the
objectives of that curriculum unit. All of the projects are aligned with Texas Essential
Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) and they are implemented in the class. With this activities,
students improve their group work skills and their ability to explain and justify their solutions.
Level II & III
Level II Mathematics PBLs are semester-long projects. Students will pick the topic from a
given list of the projects along with the instruction, helpful sites and reflection questions.
Students will begin the project at the beginning of the academic year and submit it at the
end. Teacher will support the student during the year. Teacher will ask each student to
submit a timeline to finish the project, therefore students do not have to rush at the end.
Teachers will check students’ progress and give feedback throughout the year. These
projects require construction, data collection and analyses, presentation of the findings and
reflection on the project. Each project comes with the reflection questions that students
have to answer once they finish their projects. Students have to submit the answers of the
reflection questions along with the product they have worked on (poster, research report,
construction of an objects etc.). The projects are directly intended to apply mathematics in
real life. Therefore, students will recognize the use of mathematics upon the completion of
their projects.
There is no certain list or handouts for level III. The teacher may prepare a set of project
ideas for you to choose, or the students may come with their PBL project idea and driven
question which covers the subjects you will learn from math or science classes.
English/Language Arts
Level I
The instructional model at Harmony is guided through the lens of Project Based Learning
(PBL). Instruction has moved from short term knowledge retention to long term retention by
integrating 21st Century learning experiences and embedding Texas Essential Knowledge and
Skills (TEKS) such as listening, speaking, reading, and writing as well as citizenship . These
real life experiences will prepare Harmony students for future expectations of our society and
workforce. The goal is to promote not only collaboration skills and student ownership of
learning but also to promote student success in state and national standards.
Level II & II
Level II projects are the year-long individual math or science projects that students begin
during the first quarter of the course and complete by the end of the course. Students will
complete the Level II project, including its cross-curricular requirements, in addition to the
curriculum based Level I investigations.
Level II projects should provide opportunities for the students to engage in meaningful inquiry
of personal interest at greater depth by creating and developing their own driving questions
and projects, with some support from the teacher.
Students will select one of the following options (journal, argumentative essay, narrative
essay, newspaper, or interview) to complete during the process of developing their Level II
project, or will obtain ELA teacher-permission to pursue a different option.
This ELA piece will be assessed with a common rubric. Specific deadlines will be determined
by the ELA teacher.
Social Studies
At the High School level, students will have two PBL projects to complete each year (One per
Semester) at level 1, as well as several Social Studies components to be include in the level
II and III PBL projects.
Some examples of the driving questions at this level are:
World Geography TEKS Culture 18D: “compare life in a variety of urban and rural areas in the
world to evaluate political, economic, social and environmental changes”
Driving Question: What distinctions can be drawn between Brazil and Houston on changes
to the urban environment?
World History TEKS History 1E: “identify major causes and describe the major effects of
important turning points in world history from 1750-1914...the Scientific Revolution
Driving Question: What were some effects of the Scientific Revolution in the 16
th century
on Western Culture?
U.S. History/11 TEKS History 3C: “analyze social issues affecting women, minorities, children,
immigrants, urbanization, the Social Gospel, and philanthropy of industrialists” (1877-1898)
Driving Question: Were industrial philanthropists of the late 1800s robber barons or
generous benefactors?
Level II & III
Level II & III PBLs in high school are Math/Science projects with integrated English and Social
studies components. Students in grades 9 – 12 will be asked to choose a driving question
from their Math or Science course. It is then up to the student to investigate the
connections the project has to social studies issues. The selection of a driving question and
the social studies connections should be determined by the conclusion of the first quarter.
Below are 6 ways a student can find the social studies connections to their level II and III
PBLs.
1. Historical Connection: Students should be encouraged to examine the historical
connections to a math or science problem. They can do this by exploring an event in the
past that might be related to the discovery, or an effect of the discovery on an event that
had happened as a result. For example, if a student is investigating air presser, they can
include how air pressure is related to the discovery of flight. (From the discovery of hot air
balloons in the 18
th
century, all the way through space travel).
2. Economic Influence: Students can connect a scientific discovery with its economic
impact. For example they can explain the discovery of radio waves, and the impact that has
had on business and trade. Or explain how a new product has revolutionized an industry (GM
Foods) or has caused the destruction of an existing economy.
3. Political influence: Students could investigate the role politics plays in there topic of
choice. They can trace the influence governments have on funding particular research
programs or how much funding is directed towards developing new scientists. Conversely,
students could explore how science influences politics, such as the discovery of
“greenhouse gases”.
4. Geographical influence: Students can look at how their topic can be observed in the
natural world, and investigate if geography is an influence. As volcanos, geysers and
hurricanes all have geographical influences students can make these connections and explain
how these forces can affect all of us.
5. Effect of change on Society: Students can show how the topic of their project has
influenced the way we live. Students investigating the development of computers, and show
how this technology has revolutionized our whole world. Or how discoveries in the medical
fields have changed the life expectancy, and what impact this has on culture.
6. Legal impact: Students can also look at how scientific and mathematical discoveries
have impacted our legal system. The discovery of Steam power directly led to the Gibbons
Vs. Ogden Supreme court case which decided several aspects of federal power in the United
States.
Technology Integration
Email System and Chromebooks:
● All HS school students will be provided an email account through Harmony’s Gmail
domain.
● The choice of Gmail account will allow students to use their Chromebooks for PBL
reports and digital presentations without any problems.
● All high school students will sign up for an additional email account through Gmail
domain.Students will use the Google Sites and Youtube Channels through their gmail
account.
● Students will obtain personal Google account that can be solely used for PBL
assignments
● The Gmail system ,Google sites, Google docs ,YouTube Channels, Google Plus and
PICASA albums may not be used to create any offensive or disruptive messages.
Among those which are considered offensive are any messages that contain sexual
implications, racial or gender-specific slurs, or any other comment that offensively
addresses an individual’s age, sexual orientation, religious or political beliefs, national
origin, disability, or anything that could be construed as harassment or disparaging of
others.
● Students may not use e-mail or Google sites to send, receive or post materials,
proprietary financial information, or other similar materials that violate copyright law.
Students will be responsible for any content in their Google personal site that violates
copyright law.
Level I
● In each core subject, English, Math, Social Studies, and Science, students will
complete two PBL projects in each semester.Upon completion of PBL projects in Math
and Science, students will be required to produce a digital story involving photos and
captions only (digital photo gallery presentation).
● Producing digital photo gallery presentations in Social Studies and English subjects will
be optional.
● There is a Technology Rubric for evaluation of PBL digital photo gallery presentations
at this level.
● WeVideo was selected as software tool for creating PBL digital photo gallery
presentations at this level. This decision was based on following factors: The ease of
use, seamless integration of WeVideo with Gmail and Google Drive, being an
internet-based software without the need of installation, and the ability to work with
Chromebooks.
● Training materials including video tutorials will be supplied for students and teachers
at this level. The training materials will be on how to use WeVideo for creating digital
photo gallery presentations. The video tutorials will be hosted through
pbl.harmonytx.org website.
● Produced digital photo gallery presentations will be kept in students’ Google Drive
folders for future reference.
Level II & III
● Students will complete one interdisciplinary PBL project during the academic year.
Upon completion of the PBL project, students will be required to produce;
● a digital story complete with pictures, video, sound and narration.
● a google site explaining their projects
● a brochure for their project including QR codes for movie and website link.
● Students will post their movie presentation to their YouTube Channel.
● Both movie and handout will be inserted in student’s Google Site.
● There is a Technology Rubric for the evaluation of PBL digital stories at this level.
● WeVideo will be recommended as the software tool for creating PBL digital stories at
this level. However, students will have a choice to select from other digital
storytelling software such as Photostory 3, iMovie, Animoto, and Windows Live Movie
Maker.
● Training materials including video tutorials are prepared for students and teachers at
this level. The training materials will be on how to use WeVideo and other popular
software for creating digital stories. The video tutorials will be hosted through
pbl.harmonytx.org website.
● Harmony Students’ PBL digital stories will be accepted to the Digital Storytelling
Contest (DISTCO) 2014 automatically.
● DISTCO system will host students’ PBL digital stories for future review and access.